The Case For Dividing Iraq

Anynews unrelated to Terrorism

Moderators: Cell_Leader, ikaotiki, Julstar

Post Reply
User avatar
wewant2no2
Major General [O-8]
Posts: 2739
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 5:00 am

The Case For Dividing Iraq

Post by wewant2no2 »

The most realistic option is for the U.S. to abandon the idea of creating a new, united Iraq and instead allow the country to break apart, enabling each of the country's three groups to choose its own government and provide for its own security.


With the country descending into civil war, a noted diplomat and author argues why partition may be the U.S.'s only exit strategy

Iraq is broken.

Iraq's national-unity government is not united and does not govern. Iraqi security forces, the centerpiece of the U.S.'s efforts for stability, are ineffective or, even worse, combatants in the country's escalating civil war. President George W. Bush says the U.S.'s goal is a unified and democratic Iraq, but we have no way to get there. As Americans search for answers, there is one obvious alternative: split Iraq into separate Kurdish, Sunni and Shi'ite states.

The case for the partition of Iraq is straightforward: It has already happened. The Kurds, a non-Arab people who live in the country's north, enjoy the independence they long dreamed about. The Iraqi flag does not fly in Kurdistan, which has a democratically elected government and its own army. In southern Iraq, Shi'ite religious parties have carved out theocratic fiefdoms, using militias that now number in the tens of thousands to enforce an Iranian-style Islamic rule. To the west, Iraq's Sunni provinces have become chaotic no-go zones, with Islamic insurgents controlling Anbar province while Baathists and Islamic radicals operate barely below the surface in Salahaddin and Nineveh. And Baghdad, the heart of Iraq, is now partitioned between the Shi'ite east and the Sunni west. The Mahdi Army, the most radical of the Shi'ite militias, controls almost all the Shi'ite neighborhoods, and al-Qaeda has a large role in Sunni areas. Once a melting pot, Baghdad has become the front line of Iraq's Sunni-Shi'ite war, which is claiming at least 100 lives every day.

Most Iraqis do not want civil war. But they have rejected the idea of a unified Iraq. In the December 2005 national elections, Shi'ites voted overwhelmingly for Shi'ite religious parties, Sunni Arabs for Sunni religious or nationalist parties, and the Kurds for Kurdish nationalist parties. Fewer than 10% of Iraq's Arabs crossed sectarian lines. The Kurds voted 98.7% for independence in a nonbinding referendum.

Iraq's new constitution, approved by 80% of Iraq's voters, is a road map to partition. The constitution allows Iraq's three main groups to establish powerful regions, each with its own government, substantial control over the oil resources in its territory and even its own regional army. Regional law supersedes federal law on almost all matters. The central government is so powerless that, under the constitution, it cannot even impose a tax.

American leaders seem to be in denial about these facts. President Bush continually asserts that the Iraqi people have voted for unity, while Condoleezza Rice once told me how impressed she was by the commitment of the Iraqi Kurds to building a new Iraq. James A. Baker III, co-chairman of a congressionally mandated commission tasked with formulating new policy options, has ruled out the idea of dividing Iraq. The most prominent American politician to endorse anything resembling partition is Senator Joseph Biden, who, along with former Council on Foreign Relations president Leslie Gelb, proposes dividing Iraq into three regions while maintaining a "central government in charge of common interests."

Page 1 of 6 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 Next >>
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/artic ... -2,00.html

Take care..... :wink:
stormseal
General of the Army [special]
Posts: 6563
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 4:00 am

Post by stormseal »

well i for one, and i am sure there are many of the same opinion as me, already know that unless some sort of miracle occurs then the former country that was Iraq, is no more, :arrow: FINISHED, and the main thing that is pissing the Sunni,s of is that before they had everything, they were the ones cracking the whip under Saddam, now they have next to nothing and they dont bloody like it :roll:
Image ImageYOU MUJIS
User avatar
GGenocide
Private First Class [E-3]
Posts: 73
Joined: Mon Jul 31, 2006 4:00 am

Post by GGenocide »

you still like the taste of bs. Zz. You guys make me sleep. Seriously, get a brain.
User avatar
Mr_Cookie
Sergeant Major [E-9]
Posts: 829
Joined: Sun Nov 05, 2006 5:00 am

Post by Mr_Cookie »

actually this is the plan for the new middle east

devide the arab nations into smaller peaces to have more controle over them. devide and conquer, :wink:
User avatar
weedbender
Sergeant Major [E-9]
Posts: 775
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2005 4:00 am

Post by weedbender »

It that was the case all the western countries would have done it long ago. It would have been much easier when nobody had nukes and all the military crap they have now. So no I dont agree and once we no longer need oil down the road who are they in the middle east gonna blame for still being 50 years behind everyone else?

Nevermid Im sure the US will be blamed for whatever happens in the middle east as long as fanatics and dictators ruled that part of the world.
User avatar
wewant2no2
Major General [O-8]
Posts: 2739
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 5:00 am

Post by wewant2no2 »

weedbender wrote:It that was the case all the western countries would have done it long ago. It would have been much easier when nobody had nukes and all the military crap they have now. So no I dont agree and once we no longer need oil down the road who are they in the middle east gonna blame for still being 50 years behind everyone else?

Nevermid Im sure the US will be blamed for whatever happens in the middle east as long as fanatics and dictators ruled that part of the world.
Well if they do divide the country into 3 parts. I have names all picked out....... Shiiteistine, and Sunniistine, Kurdistine.... 8O :lol: Whatch think?

Take care.... :wink:
User avatar
weedbender
Sergeant Major [E-9]
Posts: 775
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2005 4:00 am

Post by weedbender »

Me like it me like it very much. :wink:
Post Reply